Board of Property

Final Orders and Adjudications

Below is a collection of final decisions issued by the State Board of Property since 2005. Please note some of these final decisions may have been reversed or vacated on appeal.


Docket#Plaintiff/Petitioner/Appellant vs Defendant/Respondant/AppelleeFinal Order/AdjudicationDate of Order
2003-0001A. Groh Schneider, Jr. and Bonnie Schneider, Husband and Wife, Plaintiffs vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, for the use of the Pennsylvania Game Commission as "Pa. Gamelands No. 66," DefendantAdjudication and Order08.19.2005
2003-0002Ogdensburg Gun Club, a Pennsylvania nonprofit corporation, Plaintiff vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, DefendantMemorandum and Order07.07.2005
2003-0003Buffalo & Pittsburgh Railroad, Inc., Plaintiff vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Pennsylvania Game Commission, Defendant and County of Elk, IntervenorAdjudication and Order08.19.2005
2004-0001Forest Dale Farms, Inc., Plaintiff vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and Pennsylvania Game Commission, DefendantAdjudication and Order05.11.2006
2004-0002Hazle Penn, Inc. and James J. Justofin, Appellant vs Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, AppelleeMemorandum Opinion and Order07.05.2006
2005-0001Barbara K. Miller, Plaintiff vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Transportation, DefendantPraecipe for Discontinuance on Behalf of Plaintiff 06.11.2008
2005-0002Elwood Kocher and Beatrice Kocher, his wife, Plaintiffs vs Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, Jacobsburg Environmental Center and Dale W. Prinkney, Manager of the Jacobsburg Environmental Center, DefendantsOrder05.13.2010
2006-0001Larry L. Lingle, and Cynthia A. Lingle, his wife, Plaintiffs vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and the Pennsylvania Game Commission, DefendantsAdjudication and Order08.17.2007
2006-0002Frederick I. Fisher, and Ardine K. Fisher, his wife, Petitioners/Plaintiffs vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, through The Department of Environmental Protection and theof Conservation and Natural Resources, Respondent/DefendantOrder and Boundary Line Agreement04.23.2007
2007-0001Bradley T. Hutzell and Paul Buchsen, Petitioners vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, RespondentOrder05.05.2009
2007-0003Delaware Avenue, LLC, Petitioner vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, RespondentMemorandum and Order11.06.2009
2008-0001R. Neal and Linder Buterbaugh, Estate of Joseph W. Imler, Jr., Dutch Corner Historical Society, Plaintiffs vs Allen K. Stahl, DefendantAdjudication and Order10.17.2011
2008-0002Republic Services Group of Pennsylvania, LLC, successor to Ogborne Trash Removal, Inc. and Ogborne Waste Removal, Inc., Plaintiffs vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Transportation and City of Chester, Pennsylvania and Chester Resource Recovery Authority, DefendantsOpinion and Order12.10.2009
2009-0001Seneca Resources Corporation, Plaintiff vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, DefendantAgreement for Entry of Judgment02.21.2012
2011-0001Deer Ridge Lodge, Plaintiff vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, DefendantFinal Adjudication and Order01.23.2015
2011-0002International Development Corporation, Plaintiff vs Sherwood B. Davidge, Et al.,Defendants Order to Dismiss Pennsylvania Game Commission and Treasurer04.24.2015
2011-0002International Development Corporation, Plaintiff vs And Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Game Commission And Robert M. McCord, Treasurer, IntervenorsOrder to Dismiss Pennsylvania Game Commission and Treasurer04.24.2015
2012-0001Long Run Timber Company, Limited Partnership, Petitioner vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, RespondentFinal Adjudication and Order04.21.2017
2012-0001Long Run Timber Company, Limited Partnership, Petitioner vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, RespondentCorrected Final Order06.26.2017
2012-0002Ronald L. Hicks, Sr., Executor of the Estate of Rita I. Seigworth a/k/a Rita Hicks a/k/a Rita I. Siegworth, Deceased; And Mark T. Seigworth and Bobi Jo Seigworth, Husband and Wife, Claimants vs Pennsylvania Housing Finance Agency, RespondentPraecipe to Settle and Discontinue08.27.2012
2014-0002Steven G. Thompson, President, And Wildcat Hunting Club, Inc., Petitioners vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Forestry, RespondentFinal Adjudication and Order 10.23.2015
2014-0003The Estate of Rae R. Barkman, Petitioner vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Game Commission, RespondentOrder Dismissing Petition11.22.2016
2014-0004Larry D. Heasley, Petitioner vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Game Commission, RespondentOrder Dismissing Matter08.07.2015
2017-0001Sarah O’Layer McCready, Petitioner vs The Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission, RespondentFinal Adjudication and Order04.20.2018
2018-0002International Development Corp. and Atlantic Hydrocarbon, LLC., Petitioners vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Game Commission, RespondentFinal Adjudication and Order04.16.2021
2018-0003Robert W. Dunlap and Wendy J. Dunlap, Husband and Wife, Stephen W. Henning and Christina G. Henning, Husband and Wife, Donald R. Miller and Stephen C. Wintermute, Petitioners vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, RespondentFinal Memorandum Order Granting Motion to Dismiss and Dismissing Preliminary Objections as Moot07.26.2019
2018-0004Frank E. Beishline and Sandra Z. Beishline, husband and wife; Phillip M. Balisle and Patricia E. Balisle, Trustees of the Phillip M. Balisle Revocable Trust dated July 15, 2016; Ronald V. Vought, II and Karen Beth Vought, husband and wife; Clyde Bartholomew, Jr. and Judith M. Bartholomew, husband and wife; Laurie Wurster Trust; Donald J. Bowman and Kathy E. Bowman, husband and wife; Dale G. Moore and Suzanne Moore, husband and wife; and Stillwater Holdings, LLC, Petitioners vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources; and the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission, RespondentsFinal Adjudication and Order05.15.2019
2018-0005Donald L. Bussard and Barbara J. Bussard, Edward F. Lynch and Carol L. Lynch.,Petitioners vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, RespondentFinal Adjudication and Order04.15.2021
2018-0006York OPA LLC, Petitioner vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Transportation, RespondentOrder Dismissing Matter04.25.2022
2019-0001Brady's Bend, LLC, Petitioner vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, for the use of the Pennsylvania Game Commission, RespondentFinal Order Granting Complaint to Cancel Deed10.30.2019
2019-0002Edward H. Arnold and Jeanne D. Arnold, Petitioners vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Game Commission, RespondentFinal Order Granting Petition for Order to Quiet Title11.25.2019
2020-0001Golden Oil Co., Petitioner vs Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Transportation, RespondendtOrder Dismissing Matter04.25.2022
2020-0002IVN Group v. PGCFinal Adjudication and Order4.24.2023
2022-0002Steven Gidumal and Virtus Capital Advisors, LLC. v. PennDOTFinal Memorandum Order Dismissing Matter as Moot4.24.2023
2022-0001Carlino East Brandywine, LP (Petitioner)Final Adjudication and Order4.18.2024
Back To Top