Board of Property Quarterly Meeting

Click here to join the meeting: Microsoft Teams Meeting

Or call in (audio only) :
+1 267 332 8737 United States, Philadelphia

Phone Conference ID: 689 272 086#

BOARD MEMBERS

Jason E. McMurry, Esquire, chairman; designee of the Secretary of the Commonwealth
Robert Teplitz, Esquire; designee of the Secretary of Community and Economic Development
Thomas P. Howell, Esquire; designee of the General Counsel

Board Counsel

Thomas A. Blackburn, Esquire

Board Administrator

Eileen Quinn

MEETING CALL TO ORDER

MINUTES – Oct. 14, 2021

MATTERS FOR DISCUSSION

1. Hopkins v. Hanna et al; DCNR, intervenor; Docket No. BP-2008-0003
   Continued generally March 11, 2015, to permit parties to effectuate settlement
2. Thomas E. Proctor Heirs Trust and Margaret Proctor Trust v. DCNR, et al.; Docket No. BP-2014-0001
   Pleadings closed; status conference September 6, 2018.
3. Miller v. Pa. Game Cmsn. et al; Docket No. BP-2018-0001
   Pleadings closed; status conference June 27, 2019; dispositive motions to be filed
4. Beishline et al v. DEP, DCNR and Pa F&B Cmsn; Docket No. BP-2018-0004
   Remand from Cmwlth. Court reversing dismissal upon POs June 12, 2020.(Bd. member R. Teplitz recused)
   Pleadings closed. STAYED OCT. 5, 2021; Petitioners’ petition for permission to appeal memorandum order denying summary judgment
   DENIED Oct. 29, 2021; Pet. for Allowance of Appeal filed Nov. 19, 2021.
5. York OPA, LLC v. PennDoT; Docket No. BP-2018-0006
   Record Transferred from CCP; status conference Feb. 15, 2019.
6. Golden Oil Co. v. PennDoT; Docket No. BP-2020-0001
   Pleadings closed; PREHEARING CONF. April 28, 2022
7. IVN Group, LP v. Pa. Game Cmsn; Docket No. BP-2020-0002
   Pleadings closed; HEARING Jan. 19 and March 25, 2022
8. Carlino East Brandywine, LP v. Brandywine Village Associates, Leonard Blair, Richard Blair, John Cropper, Pa. Dept. of Transportation, and East Brandywine Township; Docket No. BP-2022-0001 (Bd. Member Howell recused; Julia Sheridan, Esquire as General Counsel designee) Pet. To Quiet Tile filed Feb. 8, 2022; BVA answer with motion to dismiss and pet. for declaratory judgment as against PennDoT filed Feb. 28, 2022; PennDoT answer filed March 1, 2022; PennDoT reply to new matter of BVA filed March 15, 2022; Pet. reply to new matter of BVA, Pet. motion to strike impertinent matter of BVA answer, and Pet. response to and motion to dismiss BVA pet. for declaratory judgment filed March 18, 2022; BVA answer to Pet. new matter in response to BVA motion to dismiss, BVA answer to Pet. motion to strike, and BVA answer to Pet. motion to dismiss BVA petition for declaratory relief filed March 23, 2022; BVA motion for default judgment as to its separate petition for declaratory judgment against PennDoT filed March 31, 2022; BVA motion to deem facts admitted by PennDoT filed April 4, 2022; PennDoT nunc pro tunc answer to BVA pet. for entry of declaratory judgment and answer to BVA petition for entry of default judgment, filed April 11, 2022; BVA motion to strike PennDoT’s answer to BVA pet. for declaratory judgment.
9. Steven Gidumal and Virtus Capital Advisors, LLC v. Pa. Dept. of Transportation; Docket No. BP-2022-0002
   Pet. To Quiet Tile filed Feb. 22, 2022; PennDoT answer with new matter filed March 11, 2022; Pet. reply to new matter filed April 1, 2022. Status Conference June 1, 2022.

MATTERS FOR ACTION

1. Carlino East Brandywine, LP v. Brandywine Village Associates, Leonard Blair, Richard Blair, John Cropper, Pa. Dept. of Transportation, and East Brandywine Township; Docket No. BP-2022-0001
   1. Pet. motion to strike impertinent matter of BVA answer
   2. Pet. motion to dismiss BVA pet. for declaratory judgment
   3. PennDoT request to accept nunc pro tunc answer to BVA pet. for entry of declaratory judgment and BVA motion to strke
   4. BVA motion for default judgment as to its separate petition for declaratory judgment against PennDoT and BVA motion to deem facts admitted by PennDoT

2022 MEETING DATES – January 20, April 21, August 4, October 20

ADJOURNMENT